top of page
  • Writer's pictureJosh Kiernan

Beyond Experience: Embracing an Evidence-Based Approach in Job Descriptions

In the dynamic landscape of talent acquisition, the significance of job descriptions remains unwavering. But the conventional approach of crafting job descriptions solely based on experience and qualifications is evolving. HR leaders are increasingly turning towards an evidence-based methodology to shape quality job descriptions, realizing that a nuanced and data-driven approach holds the key to attracting and retaining top talent.

typing on laptop

The Evolution of Job Descriptions

Traditionally, job descriptions revolved around qualifications, skills, and experience requirements. While these elements are undoubtedly crucial, they often fall short in capturing the essence of what makes a role successful within a specific organizational context. This led to a disconnect between what was outlined in job descriptions and the actual needs of the role.

However, the landscape is shifting. An evidence-based approach acknowledges the limitations of the traditional model and seeks to incorporate data-driven insights into job descriptions. This approach recognizes the need to focus not just on the qualifications and experience but on the behavioral competencies and cultural fit required for success in a particular role.

Crafting Quality Job Descriptions

Crafting a quality job description involves a meticulous process that goes beyond listing skills and qualifications. It starts with a deep understanding of the role, the team dynamics, and the organizational culture. Leveraging data from various sources such as performance metrics, feedback from current employees, and industry trends helps in creating a comprehensive picture of the role.

An evidence-based job description embraces language that aligns with the company's culture while clearly articulating the expectations and responsibilities. It should also encompass the behavioral competencies required for success, fostering a transparent understanding of what the role entails.

How an Evidence-Based Approach Works

The effectiveness of an evidence-based approach lies in its ability to leverage data and insights to make informed decisions. Research findings published in renowned platforms such as Harvard Business Review (HBR), Forbes, and Human Resource magazines have highlighted the advantages of this methodology.

According to an HBR article, companies that adopt an evidence-based approach in their job descriptions witness a higher rate of applications from candidates who are not only qualified but also align with the company's values and culture. Forbes' analysis emphasizes that such job descriptions lead to a more engaged workforce as employees better understand their roles and contribute meaningfully to organizational goals.

Benefits of an Evidence-Based Job Description

The advantages of embracing an evidence-based approach in job descriptions are multifold:

  1. Enhanced Candidate Fit: By outlining the behavioral competencies and cultural aspects, an evidence-based job description attracts candidates who align not only in skills but also in values, enhancing the likelihood of a successful hire.

  2. Improved Employee Engagement: Clear and comprehensive job descriptions lead to better employee understanding of their roles, fostering engagement and motivation.

  3. Reduced Turnover: When candidates have a clear understanding of what the role entails, it reduces the chances of mismatches between expectations and reality, thereby lowering turnover rates.

Implementing an Evidence-Based Approach

HR leaders play a pivotal role in implementing this approach. Collaborating with hiring managers, they can leverage data analytics and insights to shape job descriptions that resonate with both the organizational culture and the requirements of the role.

It's essential to incorporate feedback loops where the effectiveness of job descriptions is evaluated regularly. This ensures that they remain aligned with evolving organizational needs and market trends.


In a competitive job market where attracting and retaining talent is paramount, the role of a quality job description cannot be overstated. Transitioning from a traditional approach to an evidence-based methodology in crafting job descriptions not only attracts the right talent but also fosters an engaged and productive workforce.

As HR leaders and organizations embrace this paradigm shift, backed by evidence and insights, they pave the way for a more holistic and effective talent acquisition strategy. The evolution from merely describing roles to strategically articulating expectations and cultural nuances marks a significant step towards building successful teams and organizations.

The evidence-based approach in job descriptions transcends the conventional boundaries, offering a clearer and more meaningful portrayal of roles, thereby shaping the future of talent acquisition and organizational success.

Looking to transform your job description catalog? Visit Mosh JD today to learn how we can help!


Subscribe to our mailing list for more content like this.

bottom of page